Which company has more reviewer feedback specific to fire damage?

Paul Davis Toronto's review summary explicitly mentions fire damage restoration alongside water and mold, while United Water Restoration Group of Toronto's feedback is concentrated on water and flood jobs.

Which is better for a fire loss that needs rebuilding, not just cleanup?

United Water Restoration Group of Toronto's reviews highlight full reconstruction work including demolition, drywall and carpet removal, and rebuild, which lines up with major fire and smoke damage.

Do both handle insurance claims?

Yes, both are praised for guiding clients through the insurance claims process.

Which has the higher Google rating and more reviews?

United Water Restoration Group of Toronto has a 5.0 rating from 162 reviews; Paul Davis Toronto has a 4.8 rating from a larger base of 486 reviews.

United Water Restoration Group of Toronto vs Paul Davis Toronto: fire & smoke damage restoration

Updated 2026-08-12 · 17,962 reviewed · 589 listed · How we rank ›

United Water Restoration Group of Toronto and Paul Davis Toronto are both genuine options for fire and smoke damage restoration in the Toronto area, and both come up strong across our methodology. The real decision comes down to who handles a fire loss the way you need it handled: full demolition-and-rebuild with hands-on owner oversight, or a named project manager carrying the file start to finish.

Verdict

This one comes down to the shape of the damage, not the score gap between them. If the fire left you needing walls torn out and rebuilt, United Water Restoration Group of Toronto's demolition-and-reconstruction strength and hands-on owner oversight fit better. If you want a restorer whose reviewers specifically describe fire and smoke jobs, backed by a named project manager who stays with you from first call to final walkthrough, Paul Davis Toronto is the safer match.

Which should you pick?

Pick United Water Restoration Group of Toronto if

Your fire or smoke damage involves major structural loss needing demolition and full rebuild
You want an owner or supervisor personally checking equipment and progress, not just a project manager
You're prioritizing the highest rating and sentiment score over sheer review volume

Pick Paul Davis Toronto if

You want a company whose reviewers specifically vouch for fire and smoke jobs, not just water
You'd rather have one named project manager own communication for the whole job
You value a track record proven across a much larger volume of reviews (486)

The differences that matter

Fire damage track record. Paul Davis Toronto's reviewer summary explicitly calls out fire (and mold) damage handling alongside water work, while United Water Restoration Group of Toronto's feedback centers almost entirely on flood and pipe-break jobs.
Rebuild and demolition scope. United Water Restoration Group of Toronto is credited with full reconstruction work, drywall and carpet removal, and rebuild after damage, which matters when fire and smoke force structural teardown.
Who manages your job. United Water Restoration Group of Toronto reviewers describe supervisors and the owner personally checking in on jobs, while Paul Davis Toronto assigns a named project manager who owns communication from start to finish.
Scale and consistency. Paul Davis Toronto has been reviewed far more often (486 vs 162) with a slightly higher volume sub-score, while United Water Restoration Group of Toronto holds a higher rating and sentiment sub-score on a smaller base.

Side by side

Criterion	United Water Restoration Group of Toronto	Paul Davis Toronto
Google rating	5 (162 reviews)	4.8 (486 reviews)
Services	flood water extraction, 24 7 emergency response, fire smoke restoration, insurance claims assistance	flood water extraction, 24 7 emergency response, fire smoke restoration, insurance claims assistance
Best for large-loss rebuilds	Strong fit: demolition, drywall/carpet removal, and full reconstruction called out directly	The team restoration but reviews emphasize cleanup and like-new results over structural rebuild detail
Best for multi-peril damage (fire, smoke, water, mold)	Reviews focus mainly on water and flood scenarios	Reviews specifically span water, fire, and mold in the same summary
Point-of-contact style	Owner and supervisors stay hands-on across jobs	Single named project manager assigned per job
Verification	Google-verified	Google-verified
Composite score	93	91

Google rating: United Water Restoration Group of Toronto: 5 (162 reviews); Paul Davis Toronto: 4.8 (486 reviews)
Services: United Water Restoration Group of Toronto: flood water extraction, 24 7 emergency response, fire smoke restoration, insurance claims assistance; Paul Davis Toronto: flood water extraction, 24 7 emergency response, fire smoke restoration, insurance claims assistance
Best for large-loss rebuilds: United Water Restoration Group of Toronto: Strong fit: demolition, drywall/carpet removal, and full reconstruction called out directly; Paul Davis Toronto: The team restoration but reviews emphasize cleanup and like-new results over structural rebuild detail
Best for multi-peril damage (fire, smoke, water, mold): United Water Restoration Group of Toronto: Reviews focus mainly on water and flood scenarios; Paul Davis Toronto: Reviews specifically span water, fire, and mold in the same summary
Point-of-contact style: United Water Restoration Group of Toronto: Owner and supervisors stay hands-on across jobs; Paul Davis Toronto: Single named project manager assigned per job
Verification: United Water Restoration Group of Toronto: Google-verified; Paul Davis Toronto: Google-verified
Composite score: United Water Restoration Group of Toronto: 93; Paul Davis Toronto: 91

Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.

What reviewers say

United Water Restoration Group of Toronto

Reviewers consistently report same-day or next-day arrival for emergencies, with crews that work systematically through major damage (flooded basements, pipe breaks, wall removal) while keeping the home protected and clean. Staff explain the process step by step, liaise with insurers, and supervisors personally return to check equipment and progress throughout the job.

The team excels at large reconstructions-removing damaged drywall and carpet, setting up industrial drying equipment, replacing flooring-then sealing and cleaning thoroughly. Clients credit the low-stress experience to staff knowing the insurance side well and the owner staying hands-on across multiple jobs.

Paul Davis Toronto

Reviewers consistently report calm, capable handling of water, fire, and mold damage restoration. Staff explain complex processes in plain terms, follow up promptly, and deliver clean, durable results that leave customers feeling confident their homes are restored properly.

Can't decide between options?

Give the details once and receive quotes from suitable water damage restoration service in Ontario.

Enquiries from our forms may be passed to partner providers who can do the work. We may earn a referral fee, but our rankings and scores are based only on our published method, never influenced by fees.

FAQ

Which company has more reviewer feedback specific to fire damage?: Paul Davis Toronto's review summary explicitly mentions fire damage restoration alongside water and mold, while United Water Restoration Group of Toronto's feedback is concentrated on water and flood jobs.
Which is better for a fire loss that needs rebuilding, not just cleanup?: United Water Restoration Group of Toronto's reviews highlight full reconstruction work including demolition, drywall and carpet removal, and rebuild, which lines up with major fire and smoke damage.
Do both handle insurance claims?: Yes, both are praised for guiding clients through the insurance claims process.
Which has the higher Google rating and more reviews?: United Water Restoration Group of Toronto has a 5.0 rating from 162 reviews; Paul Davis Toronto has a 4.8 rating from a larger base of 486 reviews.